4th Street Bar Hive-Bar

Hive-Bar Powered by Hive beta-fdb5b5b

Community post

Sound Technique vs Surgery

I just stumbled onto this fascinating article prompted by Adele's recent cancellation of concerts following her voice breakdown relapse.

This subject piqued my curiosity because I had a few informal lessons with a first-class voice teacher about 10 years ago.

His approach was leading to a natural and effortless technique and while not being a singer I felt a dramatic positive impact in a very short time.

Here are the main points of the article

  • Adele had a vocal cord micro surgery in 2011
  • All credit was given to the surgeon and the procedure.
  • Hundreds and hundreds of famous and non-famous singers have broken their voices and turned to such vocal cord surgery.
  • While this affliction used to be common to older singers with decades-old careers, it now occurs frequently with singers in their teens or twenties.
  • The whole artistic world is embracing the path of surgery.
  • Brilla & Paglin, two voice teachers who dedicated their life to safe and enduring singing technique stated in 2011 that the surgery was a fix and unless the technical approach be changed, trouble would most likely come again.
  • They have studied for decades, taking as starting point opera singers and other strong voices who still had outstanding voices in their seventies and eighties.
  • They believe they hold the key to proper teaching of young singers and helping more experienced singers who have damaged their vocal cords.
  • Their approach goes against modern conventional wisdom and is not embraced by the singing teaching community at large.

It's a long read but it's worth it.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c2/Frank_Sinatra_by_Gottlieb_c1947-_2.jpg

3 upvotes $0.00

Replies (1)

Review before signing

Posting as . Signing with . Keychain permission: Posting. Hive Keychain will ask you to approve this action next.


  
Technical details

Operation fingerprint: